20VC: Benchmark's Newest General Partner Ev Randle on Why Margins...

Full Title

20VC: Benchmark's Newest General Partner Ev Randle on Why Margins Matter Less in AI | Why Mega Funds Will Not Produce Good Returns | OpenAI vs Anthropic: What Happens and Who Wins Coding | Investing Lessons from Peter Thiel and Mamoon Hamid

Summary

The episode features Everett Randle, a new General Partner at Benchmark, discussing investment strategies in the AI era.

Key themes include the evolving VC landscape, lessons learned from prominent investors, the unique characteristics of AI companies versus SaaS, and Benchmark's approach to investing despite differing fund sizes and strategies compared to mega-funds.

Key Points

• Benchmark's investment strategy focuses on being the closest and most impactful partner to founders while aiming for the highest money-on-money returns for LPs, irrespective of ownership percentage, adapting to current asset class realities.
• There's a need for a new taxonomy for AI companies, as their financial metrics and business models differ significantly from traditional SaaS, particularly concerning gross margins due to inference costs.
• Learning from mentors like Mary Meeker, Peter Thiel, and Mamoon Hamid provided valuable insights on using quantitative data to drive narratives, testing conviction through firm structure, and developing impeccable taste in identifying exceptional founders and products.
• The mega-fund model, driven by capital velocity and the need to deploy large checks, may not always yield the best fund-level returns compared to smaller, more focused funds like Benchmark, which prioritize deeper relationships and potentially higher cash-on-cash returns.
• The VC industry is bifurcating between high-velocity, lower-touch "Tiger-like" models and high-touch, craft-focused firms like Benchmark, with a potential "dead zone" for mid-sized firms lacking a clear strategy.
• The success of AI companies will be driven by technology and talent scarcity, not solely distribution, as building exceptional AI products is complex and requires specialized expertise, creating a strong moat.
• Early-stage investing requires a focus on people and product quality, while later stages are more influenced by market size, but the ability to adapt and pivot is crucial for long-term success.
• The definition of a "golden category" may expand due to AI, as it can create significant net new ARR by touching labor forces and enhancing efficiency across various sectors.
• The transition of human labor budgets to AI software spend is a key indicator of future economic shifts and the success of AI companies.
• Investors should focus on gross profit dollars per customer and gross margin projections for AI companies over a longer time horizon, rather than solely comparing them to SaaS metrics.
• The critical success factor for AI companies is differentiation from foundational models and labs, offering distinct workflows and value propositions to justify their pricing.
• Large tech companies are increasingly being valued on their ability to drive absolute gross profit per customer, even with lower gross margins, similar to AWS's success.
• The venture capital industry is not commoditized; firms with strong, differentiated strategies and exceptional talent will continue to thrive, with a focus on building truly valuable companies.
• The "AI inference cloud" business model, initially perceived as a commodity reselling play, has proven to be a significant market opportunity due to immense demand, justifying potentially lower margins.
• While mega-funds might struggle to achieve the same money-on-money returns as smaller, focused funds, their absolute dollar returns can still be substantial, making fund size and strategy alignment crucial for LPs.
• Benchmark's approach emphasizes being a valuable partner to founders and delivering exceptional returns by focusing on the best companies, rather than adhering to a specific ownership percentage or stage.
• The firm's success is built on its team's individual investing styles, guided by core North Stars of LP returns and founder partnership, allowing flexibility in stage and sector focus.
• The shift from human labor budgets to AI software spend represents a significant economic transition, with AI poised to drive GDP growth and societal prosperity by increasing efficiency.
• The key to navigating the current AI boom and potential downturn is to remain disciplined, focus on fundamental value, and maintain flexible fund structures to weather market volatility.
• Mega-funds may face challenges in day-to-day operations due to large teams and limited coverage per investor, potentially leading to a focus on "local maxima" rather than the absolute best opportunities.
• Founders seek partners who push them and provide constructive criticism, rather than "yes-men," and the best VCs are those who can offer this balance.
• Investing in companies with strong usage metrics and developer engagement is critical for AI product improvement and long-term success, as these factors drive rapid advancement.
• Founders Fund's ability to incubate companies and produce exceptional returns makes it a highly desirable firm for LPs seeking differentiated outcomes.
• A "missed" investment in a high-growth company like OpenAI at an early stage can be painful, highlighting the importance of not letting structural concerns overshadow fundamental potential.
• Stasis and a lack of adaptation to evolving market dynamics pose the greatest threat to established venture capital firms like Benchmark.
• Benchmark's success hinges on its ability to maintain relationships with the best companies and founders, which serves as the primary currency in the venture capital asset class.
• While AI has the potential to disrupt many industries, the "AI inference cloud" sector has shown strong performance due to overwhelming demand, suggesting that business quality concerns may be secondary for now.
• The VC industry's success is measured by the quality of its portfolio companies and the returns generated for LPs, with a focus on finding "generational" companies.
• The greatest threat to Benchmark's long-term success is stagnation, emphasizing the need to remain adaptable and focused on securing partnerships with top-tier companies.
• The venture capital industry is not commoditized, and firms with strong, differentiated strategies and talent will continue to produce superior returns.
• The focus should be on identifying companies with strong usage and developer engagement, as these are key indicators of AI product improvement and market leadership.
• Founders at Benchmark are unlikely to regret their partnership, suggesting a strong track record of positive founder relationships and value creation.

Conclusion

The venture capital industry is undergoing a significant shift, with AI companies requiring new evaluation frameworks beyond traditional SaaS metrics.

Firms like Benchmark, with their focused strategy and commitment to founders, are well-positioned to navigate market changes and deliver strong returns, even if their approach differs from mega-funds.

AI is expected to be a major driver of economic growth, increasing productivity and prosperity, and it is crucial for investors to identify companies that can capture this potential while remaining adaptable to market volatility.

Discussion Topics

• How do venture capital firms adapt their strategies to the unique financial characteristics of AI companies compared to traditional SaaS businesses?
• What are the key lessons learned from experienced investors like Peter Thiel and Mamoon Hamid that are most relevant for emerging VC professionals today?
• With the increasing prevalence of AI, how should the venture capital industry redefine its core metrics for success and its approach to building long-term relationships with founders?

Key Terms

LPs

Limited Partners, typically institutional investors like pension funds and endowments that commit capital to venture capital funds.

Capital Velocity

A strategy in venture capital focused on investing capital rapidly to maximize the number of deals and potentially achieve higher overall returns, even if individual deal returns are lower.

Golden Category

A market segment that experiences significant net new Annual Recurring Revenue (ARR) growth in a single year, indicating a high-growth opportunity for investors.

TAM

Total Addressable Market, the total market demand for a product or service.

Net New ARR

Net New Annual Recurring Revenue, the increase in predictable revenue over a year.

NPS

Net Promoter Score, a metric used to gauge customer loyalty and satisfaction.

Conways Law

A concept stating that organizations design systems that mirror their own communication structure, often applied to software development and team organization.

GP

General Partner, the active managers of a venture capital fund who make investment decisions and manage portfolio companies.

SaaS

Software as a Service, a software distribution model where a third-party provider hosts applications and makes them available to customers over the Internet.

AI Inference

The process of using a trained AI model to make predictions or decisions on new data.

Coggs

Cost of Goods Sold, the direct costs attributable to the production or purchase of the goods sold by a company.

VC

Venture Capital, financing that investors provide for startup companies and small businesses that are believed to have long-term growth potential.

Timeline